Village Handed Legal Setback in Dispute with Palmer Trinity School
Palmer Trinity School Wins Court Victory in Ongoing Zoning Dispute with the Village of Palmetto Bay
The Village of Palmetto Bay was dealt a legal setback on Wednesday in a continuing battle with a local private school over plans to expand the school’s campus and increase enrollment.
Palmer Trinity School secured a legal victory against the village in an appellate court ruling delivered Wednesday.
The court’s decision paves the way for the school to reseek a zoning change, but it does not guarantee the school will get the approval of a major expansion.
The legal wrangling began when the village council, acting in their capacity as the village zoning board, denied Palmer’s application for a zoning change.
In May, 2009, the school filed two lawsuits against Palmetto Bay after the zoning request was denied.
Round one of the battle went to Palmetto Bay, as a Miami-Dade judge upheld the village council’s decision.
Palmer appealed that ruling, through Florida’s Third District Court of Appeals.
On Wednesday, that appellate court overturned the local judge’s ruling, meaning the village will have to reconsider its decision.
The dispute is far from over – Palmetto Bay may now appeal the decision or approve the zoning change. Even if the zoning change is approved, Palmer would still be required to submit a separate application and receive a separate approval for the desired school expansion.
Palmer Trinity is a private school with an enrollment of approximately 600 students. Located at 7900 SW 176th St., the school hopes to expand from 600 to 1,400 students, add additional parking, and build a chapel, gymnasium, and other amenities.
Nearby neighborhoods have been vocal in their disapproval of the plan, citing increased traffic, noise and an overall disintegration of their quality of life.
We would like to hear your thoughts - and we’ll post your comments and suggestions on the blog :
As a resident, how do you feel about the dispute between the village and Palmer Trinity?
Is there a way to balance the expansion plans of the school with the expectations of the residents to the quiet enjoyment of their neighborhood?
Have all parties negotiated in good faith?
Most importantly, can anything be done differently in the future to avoid such costly and protracted legal confrontations?
Residents – let your voices be heard!
Loading ...